« Home | Syria jails four Kurdish militants » | Lebanese warlord Jaja walks out of prison » | Saad Al-Hariri: there are no Syrian intelligence o... » | Saad Al-Hariri: leave Hizbollah alone » | Saad Al-Hariri hints at Lahoud's involvement in Ra... » | Israel prosecutes Syrian hairdressers who want to ... » | Syria puts 7500 troops on the Iraqi border » | Murr: 'Pressing need to rebuild security structure... » | Anyone understand Condaleeza Rice? Spot the differ... » | Syria faces risk from Al-Qaida coming from Iraq, U... » 

Wednesday, July 27, 2005 

The Price of Jaja?

It wasn't just warlord Jaja who walked free today, a few days ago Muslim militants with links to Al-Qaeda were also released.

It was part of Parliament's plan not to look biased towards Lebanon's far-right. Their convictions remain valid, they are all murderers, but they were let out on to the streets as part of Lebanon's dirty politics. The price of Jaja's release.

Much of Lebanon is already worried that Jaja will reform and strengthen his Lebanese Forces miltia. Now there's the added fear that the plague of Al-Qaeda that Iraq, Syria and Egypt are suffering from will spread back into Lebanon.

Jaja killed Muslims, Druze, Christians, and even members of his own party. And recently, his supporters have fought rivals on the streets of Beirut.

Most commentators argue that Islamic terrorism is a fanatical perversion of Islam which deviates from its true teachings. They call for a Western-style modernization of the Muslim world, hoping thereby that radical Islam will be tamed.

This analysis misses the point. The nature of the terrorist threat is unambiguously Islamic and is not so much a deviation from Muslim tradition as an appeal to it. Al Qaeda's ideology draws on two traditions to legitimize itself: one classical, the other modern.

Regarding classical Islam, the oft-quoted remark that Islam is a religion of peace is false. It is historically illiterate to claim that war is foreign to Islam and it is theologically uninformed to argue that jihad is merely a personal inner struggle with no external military correlate.

On the contrary, Islam is linked from the beginning with the practice of divinely sanctioned warfare and lethal injunctions against apostates and unbelievers. Islam experienced no period of wandering and exclusion; from its inception, Islam formed a unitary state bent on military conquest.

The Prophet died a successful military leader who created a single Islamic polity that expanded - through warfare - all over the known world. The caliphate combined the double logic of a religious community and an imperial state.

This dual identity explains how Islam can be simultaneously peaceful and warlike. While the Koran enjoins that there shall be "no compulsion in religion," Islam still regards it as a holy duty to extend militarily the borders of the House of Islam against the demonic world of unbelievers: "He who dies without having taken part in a campaign dies in a kind of unbelief."

Coupled with this irreconcilability between Islam and its enemies is an extreme territorial sense of the sacred. Hence bin Laden's principal demand for the departure of all infidels from holy Muslim lands. When extremists say they are killing in the name of Islam, they are in part appealing to Islamic traditions of long standing. Al Qaeda's modern origins go back to Wahhabism, named after the revivalist movement founded by Muhammad Ibn'Abd al-Wahhab in 1744. Wahhab called for a return to a pure and unadulterated form of Islam closer to the ideals of the Prophet.

Faced with a decadent society, Wahhabism (not unlike some radical Protestant sects) reduced Islam to a scriptural literalism, an absolutism utterly hostile to other more medieval traditions. In this sense of direct rule by God, Wahhabism is a truly modern theology. Not unlike Descartes and Kant, it argues for the unmediated and total knowledge of its object.

Al Qaeda then blended this theology with fascism. The Indian Muslim Abu Ala Maududi (1903-1979) condemned the degraded nature of all contemporary Muslim communities. He characterized Muslim governments that did not implement stringent Islamic law as apostate and commanded true believers to wage jihad against them.

Maududi was a decisive influence on Sayyid Qutb (1906-1966), chief ideologue of the Muslim Brotherhood. Like Maududi, Qutb fused the history of Mohammed's travails with a revolutionary vanguard-type ideology that removed medieval limits on warfare by championing a modern death cult in the quest for a revivified caliphate.

The ideology instigated by these two figures is fuelled by dreams of a prior Islamic golden age. Al Qaeda sympathizers avidly read European fascist literature and pursue religious ends via atheist methods. Recruits to the cause are not the excluded uneducated poor, they are intellectuals with a radical critique of Western society and its impact on Islam.

Neither the "war on terror" nor political negotiations will overcome Islam's totalitarian turn. Western repression is everywhere fuelling the ranks of radical Islam. Equally, there can be no accommodation with an ideology that seeks to fashion the whole world in its own image. The essentially Islamic nature of this terror demands nothing less than a reformation in the name of an alternative Islam.

Islam, with good reason, will never embrace Western secularization. But it could begin to develop a critique of its history by recovering some of its aborted traditions. Islam must place true religious conversion (like that of Sufism) over territorial conquest.

Islam needs to restore the legislative authority of communal consensus to allow Muslims to develop along with, rather than against, the future.

great, intelligent well thought our piece of writing....

100% correct, and on point.

False piece of irrelevant off-topic writing. Christians are just as prone to violence as Muslims. The Lebanese Civil War taught us that.

HOW CAN YOU EXPLAIN THE EXCISTAT OF MANY CHRISTIANS IN THE ARAB WOURLD YES ISLAM WAS THE SPIRITUAL DRIVE FOR THE LIBERATION OF THE ARAB LAND IN THE SEVENTH CENTURY FROM THE ROMAN AND THE PERSIAN ISLAM WAS AXCEPTED BY THE POPULATION BECAUSE OF IT,S MERSIFULL NATURE DIDN,T THE CHRISTIAN GIVE THE KEYS TO JERUSELIM TO KALIFAT OMAR,I AM CHRISTIAN FROM SYRIA ,I NEVER FELT ABUSED OR DISCREMINATED AGAIST I ACTUALY WENT TO DAMASCUS UNIVERSITY WITHOUT PAYING ANY TUTION ,THE PART THAT THE WEST DOES NOT UNDERSTAND IS THAT ALL ARABS NOT ONLY MUSLEMS ARE ANGRY ABOUT WHAT THE WEST DID TO THE ARABS STARTING IN THE BEGINING OF THE TWENTIETH SENCURY FROM PROMISES TO SHEREF HUSSIN ABOUT INDEPENDENCE IN RETURN FOR THE ARAB REVOLT AGAINST TURKY ,A MUSLEM BUT OCCUPYING POWER TO FIND OUT THAT ENGLAND PROMISED PALESTINE TO THE HEBREWS COSPIRED WITH FRANCE TO DEVIDE THE ARAB LAND INTO SMALL WEAK COUNTRIES WITH DEFERENT LEGAL AND ECONOMIC SYSTEMS SO THEY HAVE HARD TIME IN UNIFECATION SEEN WITH FAILED ATTEMPT AT THE UNION BETWEEN SYRIA AND AGYPT ,SYRIA AND IRAQ ,SYRIA ,AGYPT AND LIBIA WHAT ALQAIDA IS DOING IS USING THE INPIRATION OF ISLAM IN DEFFENDING FIRST THE ARAB NATION AND PUNISH THE WEST FOR THEIR DEEDS ,UNTILL THE WEST RECOGNISE WHAT THEY DID AND ADMIT THEIR HOSTILITY TOWARDS THE ARABS AND CORRECT WHAT THEY DID HOSTILITY TOWARD THE WEST WILL CONTINUE.THE WEST SHOULD LEAVE THE ARAB LAND AND SHOULD ABIDE WITH INTERNATIONAL LAW IN PALESTINE KASHMIR UNTILL THEN TERROR IS THE WEAK RESPONSE TO THE POWERFULL.

if it was'nt for jaja lebanon would of been syria or even palistine thanks to jaja and his people for putting there foot down they are the true soilders of lebanon not puppets like lahood
& the 99% of the cowards with in its own government welcome back dr samir jaja

Post a Comment

Links to this post

Create a Link

About me

  • Written by sasa
  • From Damascus, Syria
  • From Damascus to London via Beirut. Based in and out of the central Damascene hamlet of Saroujah. News and feelings from the streets every day. I'm talking rubbish? Leave a comment. Welcome to the information democracy. See below for info about this site.
My profile

Syria News Wire discussion

Syria News Wire - the most comprehensive source of Syrian news on the web

  • The Syria News Wire now provides news for Cafe-Syria. To find out how to get exclusive Syrian news for your site, click here.

Get Syria News Wire EMAIL UPDATES

  • the important stuff: you can cancel any time, your email address wont be used for anything except Syria News Wire updates - this is an ad-free site
  • Enter your email address below to subscribe to The Syria News Wire...